Monday, July 18, 2011

Engineering is All About Challenges.

The recent dust up over repealing the 2007 light bulb energy standards got me thinking. I’ve been in engineering for over 35 years now, but I really started that journey at age 6 watching the attempted launch of Vanguard TV3 on the family’s tiny black and white TV screen. Right then, I was captured by the challenge of “How can this be made to work?” Although I didn’t realize it then, that was when I became an engineer. By the time I graduated from college the space program had wound down but the first “oil crisis” was upon us and the new challenge was energy. I gravitated to power electronics and have been involved with the challenges of converting electrical energy from one form to another ever since.

Many of the challenges we face as engineers are market driven such as reducing the life cycle cost of equipment or redesigning obsolete equipment, but some are the result of the broader goals of society to improve life. The goals of urban sanitation in the late 19th century and auto safety of the late 20th century both come to mind.

The 2007 energy legislation set several goals beyond light bulbs, such as electric motor and appliance efficiency. All of these challenges triggered development of solutions, much of it here in the United States, which continue today. They are already having the intended effect of improving overall efficiency.

Rolling back even the lighting efficiency standards would be like deciding we could get by without seatbelts or baby car seats. In 12 years we overcame the Vanguard failure to land men on the moon; we can build a better light bulb.

My message to our government representatives is; bring on the challenges and set or raise the bar. The only thing you can’t do is violate the laws of physics.

Engineers meet challenges; it’s what we do.

Friday, March 18, 2011

Japan, Energy and Infrastructure

Like a lot of people, I've been following the events unfolding in Japan after the earthquake as well as the worldwide reaction and I can't help putting my engineering hat on. I was in college at UCLA when the now damaged Fukushima nuclear plant was under construction. Coincidently at the time, the United States was also going through the first "energy crises" with high gas prices brought on by suppliers in the Middle East. The UCLA engineering school quickly put together classes and seminars on energy topics, including understanding how energy was then produced,  future supplies, efficiency and even renewable energy. As a student, it was clear to me then that this had to be addressed by my generation. 


Fast forward 38 years. The verdict on our accomplishments is mixed. Yes, we did make improvements in efficiency and some improvements in supply but little progress toward sustainable energy. We basically still get all our energy the same way the cave man did; we burn stuff. Back then it was wood, today it's burning fossil fuels or a hot pile of decaying rocks. There are other ways to extract energy, particularly chemically as is done in biology, or fusion which is how the sun operates. We touched on that in those seminars 38 years ago but for various reasons never throughly pursued them.


In my opinion, we failed miserably on another issue that was obvious back then; infrastructure. The Fukushima complex is almost 40 years old. Why was it still operating? We don't even keep sports stadiums that long! An entire generation of engineers has had the opportunity to improve on that basic design yet it didn't happen. Here in the US, we haven't built a new nuclear power plant since the '70's. Fortunately, the Navy continued using nuclear energy, so design improvements have been made, but we haven't applied them to replacing these old power plants. Think about it. The next generation will be the most energy dependent generation ever but the foundation of their supply would have been built by their grandparents. 


Infrastructure does not last forever.

Sunday, March 6, 2011

Erland Persson

On February 22  the world lost a true genius. My mentor and friend, Erland Persson passed away. I worked for Erland back in the early ‘80’s and it is he who taught me the basics of motion control and encouraged in me the confidence, optimism  and sheer love of engineering that still excites me today.

My job interview with Erland for an R&D position at Electro Craft in Hopkins, MN 30 years ago was a turning point for me. Right from the start we discovered common ground in music, science, engineering and even history. That lunch meeting was both the longest and shortest interview of my life. Long in that it lasted all afternoon, short in that it flew by.

At EC, Erland encouraged me to try my wings as an engineering manager (I wasn’t any good at it). At the end of the day we would gather in his office and ponder “What if”, usually regarding some engineering problem we were facing, but often we would drift into solving other problems or even dreaming up new products. At the start of my stint at Electrocraft, he would encourage me to not be so silent, by the end of my tenure there; I was confidently presenting papers at conferences and dealing with customers and staff alike. Somewhere there is a picture of Erland, myself and other young Electrocraft engineers on the beach in Santa Barbara CA. We had gone there to visit a sister division, Renco, and it became a true bonding event for the team.

We were all caught up in the recession of 1986 when Electrocraft management decided to close the R&D department. To his credit, Erland used his extensive contacts in the industry to provide a steady parade of what turned out to be potential employers through the facility, and most of the staff quickly found employment. I had gained enough confidence to strike out on my own, at least for a while, discovering to my surprise that I actually could make it and support my family (and this was pre internet!). I’ve always felt I’ve had Erland at my back.

Erland also struck out on his own at that point, and we continued to collaborate on projects for the next 20 years. With his help, we demystified motion control for a variety of clients and came up with some pretty unique solutions.

Then in 2006, I decided to go on my own full time. I called Erland to tell him the news, he told me he was winding down from consulting and we set up a lunch date. The morning of the meeting, he called to apologize that he had to fly to Detroit to meet a client and couldn’t make it. I said “But aren’t you now retired?”. He replied “yes, but they need me”. That was the essential Erland.

I ran into him once more, at an IEEE Twin Cities banquet a few years ago. He announced to me there that he was really hanging it up. I’m not sure I believed him until I heard that he didn’t renew the Magnetic Finite Element software he had been using. Then I knew he was really retiring.

Now I’ve been on my own full time for almost 5 years and have weathered the worst recession in 80 years, unscathed.

I said earlier I’ve always felt Erland was at my back

He still is.

Gary Box

Monday, February 14, 2011

Comfort Zone

A lot of people do not operate well when they are out of their comfort zone. The same is true for companies. An organization that has been designing and building analog based power conversion equipment may be forced out of their comfort zone when a customer needs visibility into the equipment via CAN or some other digital protocol. By switching to an all digital control scheme, this form of inflexibility can be overcome. However, the very concept of switching from analog to digital control may be daunting. A similar, even more basic, disconnect occurs when a primarily mechanical company takes on electronic control.

At GBOX LLC we have been straddling the fence between power electronics and embedded control for 30 years. We understand the trade offs and what can be done. More importantly, we know what can't be done.

In the coming weeks, we will be rolling out a unified concept for bringing intelligence to power conversion. Stay tuned as we tackle some new but tough applications.

Friday, December 3, 2010

Reliability

The wall is beginning to crack open. Maybe it's all the press about energy efficiency or maybe it's induction motor consumers looking for something higher tech, but the benefits of BLDC technology are sinking in.
However, they is one important hang up. Many manufacturers who now use induction motors in their products have never had electronics, much less power electronics, in their products. It's a new technology to them and they are understandably reluctant to take the risk. Unfortunately, unlike its lower powered cousins, power electronics can fail dramatically. Some manufacturers have had bad experiences in the past where failures released the "magic smoke" of burning electronics. An interesting case in point was the recent failure on the new Boeing 787 in flight tests. Here is a link describing that system http://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/qtr_4_07/article_02_1.html
Here is a link describing a probable cause:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-11-24/boeing-787-said-to-need-redesign-of-electrical-parts-after-fire.html

All of us in the power electronics industry must do our part to enhance and demonstrate reliability. There is no inherent reason a motor drive or an inverter can't be as reliable as century old technologies like induction motors, but we are going to have to prove it to the world.

To that end, we at the IEEE Twin Cities chapter Power Electronics Society (PELS), of which I am a member, are presenting talk by Eric Persson of International Rectifier on "A fresh look at FET failure mechanisms during fast switching"


Click on the link to go to the IEEE site for the meeting details.


Hopefully, under the PELS banner we can foster more discussion of this topic.

Sunday, September 26, 2010

Start ups

The NY Times recently published the results of a study on job creation that refined the concept that most new jobs come through small business. The twist was that the vast majority of new jobs were in new businesses, both small and large. All recessions are a time of turbulent business evolution, with some business models fading away and new ones emerging. I've been through many in 34 years  but this one is by far the most evolutionary. Business models that have stood for over a century in manufacturing, publishing, transportation and communication are dying. The opportunity is that the needs are not going away. If anything, they are even greater. What will change is the business model for meeting those needs.

An interesting nuance this time around is that the 2010 model start up can hit the ground running by outsourcing, just like the big boys, but without the overhead. At GBOX LLC we have clients that we meet with over the internet via web meetings. We team up with other vendors and collaborate electronically. We even observe and run tests remotely or have client and team members observe tests in our lab remotely. Within the U.S., overnight shipping has reduced transportation delays to  a minimum.

At the same time, awareness of  the life-cycle costs of electrical powered equipment has grown. We are all aware of the energy cost of running our cars because we are reminded every time we fill up. That hasn't been true for electric motor use. The Department of Energy estimates that the cost of running a standard induction motor 24/7 for 10 years is 50 times the original purchase price. Just a 10% increase in energy can have a big payback. In fact, the the Energy Independence and Security Act of  2007, which becomes effective on December 19, 2010, requires minimum energy ratings for particular classes of induction motors.

It's a perfect time to get out the "white sheet of paper" and redesign motor driven products or systems that haven't been touched in years, something start ups are uniquely suited for. We can help you drill down to use the latest motor and power electronics to achieve efficiencies above 90%.

Good luck to the 2010 class of start ups out there and let me know if you could use us on your team.

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Welcome!

Welcome to my blog on Digital Power.
What is Digital Power? It's the combination of digital intelligence in the form of micro controllers and digital signal processors to the general problem of handling power. It's estimated by the IEEE that 60% of all electricity in the United States passes through a semiconductor sometime between generation and consumption, a figure that will eventually reach 100%- and that's grid power. Off grid, digital power can be found in hybrid vehicles, electric actuators to replace hydraulics and even lawnmowers.

Why is this important? One word; efficiency. For example, 65% of all electricity in the U.S. is used by motors running at 60% to 70% efficiency. Digital power can boost these efficiencies to 90%+ and every watt not consumed is a watt that doesn't need to be generated (or paid for). That's by far the greenest, and cheapest, energy available!

From time to time I'll post developments in and comments on this not very visible but vital field. Feel free to add your comments or ask questions.

As for my background; I'm a consultant in the field of Digital Power Conversion. You can check out my website at www.gboxllc.com or follow me on Twitter @digpwrengr.

Again, thanks for stopping by!